Supporting copy for the Request Service call out button.
Located in New Palestine, IN
Mama Nitas Pizza Logo
Because Mama Says!
New Palestine, IN - 317-861-1300


Exceptional Authentic Italian
and American Cuisine

Locally and Family Owned | Catering Is Available | Authentic Family Recipes

Locally and Family Owned
Catering Is Available
Authentic Family Recipes

Contact Us

Unbelievably Good Pizza

Are you craving a pizza? From traditional pies to unique specialty recipes, we've got a complete range of pizzas that can satisfy any crowd. Contact any of our locations in Greenfield, and New Palestine, IN, for dine in, carry out, or delivery!
Learn More
variety of pizza toppings

Everyone Loves Appetizers

Get some for yourself or share with your friends! Appetizers are a great way to start off any meal at Mama Nitas Pizza. Choose from classic favorites such as mozzarella sticks or something different like our loaded fries!
Learn More
chicken wings

Try Our Flavorful Subs and Hoagies

Make your next lunch or dinner a truly memorable experience with the absolutely delicious subs and hoagies available at Mama Nitas Pizza. From chicken parm to Philly cheesesteaks, we do it all.
Learn More
three subs

Happy Customer Reviews

Quality Food, Friendly Service, and Great Prices

Contact Us to Cater Your Next Event

TVs and FREE Wi-Fi in All Locations

Gluten-Free, Vegan, and Keto-Friendly Options

Kid-Friendly Options

Members of Helping Hands for Freedom
Share by: